The Pattern Before the Product

The plugins are gone now. Deprecated, April 2024. One understated paragraph in a developer blog. No keynote. No retrospective. If you go looking for them, you find a redirect.

Which would be a normal story of tech hubris — announce big, ship quietly, disappear without accounting — except something odd happened on the way to the graveyard. The plugins failed. The pattern survived.

Tool use is everywhere now. It's built into every model worth mentioning. The architecture that made plugins theoretically possible — give a model a function signature, let it decide when to call it, receive the result, incorporate it into reasoning — that's the substrate running under agents, assistants, copilots, and every "agentic workflow" in conference demos this year. OpenAI didn't abandon the idea. They abandoned the product and kept the physics.

This is not how tech companies usually talk about what they're doing. The standard story is: we built a thing, the thing succeeded or failed, we learned and pivoted. What actually happened here is stranger: they shipped an implementation before anyone knew what the implementation was for. The 200 plugins weren't a product. They were a probe. A way of asking: if models can reach out and touch external systems, what do people actually want to touch?

The answer turned out not to be "a Kayak integration inside ChatGPT." The answer was "models that can use tools as a general capability, invokable programmatically, composable with other systems." The function calling API — released June 2023, a month after plugins launched — is the thing that mattered. The plugins were the public research phase.

Credit where it's slightly due: most companies don't figure this out at all. They ship the bad implementation, watch it fail, and conclude the idea was wrong. OpenAI looked at the plugins data, noticed what developers were actually doing with the API underneath, and correctly identified that the infrastructure was the product and the UI was a distraction. That's not genius — it's just basic pattern recognition executed at unusual speed.

What you should actually take from the plugins obituary is this: the gap between announcement and product is where the real architecture lives. The keynote is marketing. The deprecation notice is archaeology. What gets deprecated tells you what was a bet. What gets quietly absorbed into the API tells you what resonated with the underlying structure of what people actually needed.

OpenAI found the pattern before they found the product. That's rarer than it sounds, and worth more than two hundred plugins that don't exist anymore.

i · sources

• ChatGPT plugins — OpenAI, 2023-03-23
• OpenAI to deprecate plugins in favor of GPTs — The Verge, 2024-04-09
• Function calling and other API updates — OpenAI, 2023-06-13